PR pundits and brand watchers love to create "best and worst" lists around marketing and communications developments. The emphasis usually falls on the
"worsts"—like the most poorly handled crisis situations or mangled cover-ups.
It's easy to criticize, but what about giving credit for crises averted or PR battles won? That list is shorter and perhaps a bit less obvious, but
here are my nominations.
Penney's reputation has endured some bumps in the past year. First, it was outed by The New York Times
for "black hat" SEO practices last January
. Then, it
suffered a visual identity crisis
leading up to the announcement of a bold new pricing strategy
. Just as
it built positive momentum for the "new" JCP, advocacy group One Million Moms threatened a store boycott
choice of ad spokesperson Ellen DeGeneres.
Rather than try to appease critics, the company stood by Ellen and, in a brilliant move, it escaped the Lowe's
trap by letting her
do most of the talking. Penney's was betting that Ellen was far more popular than One Million Moms, and it was right.
Ellen's explanation of her "traditional values
" is a PR home
run. The boycott ended
than a flash sale.
Planned Parenthood (PP)
Most of the coverage of the Susan G. Komen/Planned Parenthood debacle focused on
Komen's lack of preparedness for the public reaction
after it dropped PP from its grants program. But Planned Parenthood mounted a first class response to the potential crisis.
After offering an exclusive
to the AP, it let loose a barrage of news releases and launched a social media campaign
to mobilize fans. Its core
strategy was simple; as spokesperson Tait Sye explained, "We gave people things to do." PP circulated online petitions, shared tweets, posted comments,
and launched a no-holds-barred media tour by telegenic CEO Cecile Richards. The public pressure forced SGK to backpedal within the week
A year ago, the fast-food chain was the target of a customer lawsuit
that served up a
potential PR disaster for its brand. A California woman smacked Taco Bell with deceptive marketing claims, saying its tacos have far less beef than
advertised. Taco Bell wasted no time in firing back.
The chain went on the offense, big time. It filed a countersuit, posted a video statement from the CEO, and dished out a saucy media campaign featuring
the headline "Thank You for Suing Us!" The customer's beef, and her lawsuit, were quietly dropped
ensuring Taco Bell a place in the annals of crisis management. Well done.
The Red Cross
It was only a rogue tweet, so the risk faced by The American Red Cross last year may not rise to the level of reputation crisis. But its handling of a
staffer's Twitter post about a party was a nice example of a measured response.
After realizing the employee
confused a personal account with a corporate one
and shared plans for "gettingslizzerd" on @RedCross, the tweet was quickly deleted. Yet, importantly, it wasn't ignored. The Red Cross used a light
touch, noting, "We've deleted the rogue tweet but rest assured the Red Cross is sober and we've confiscated the keys." Best of all, @DogfishBeer joined
the fun by encouraging donations, and appropriate replenishment.
Oh, baby, what a mess this could have been. When the teen pop star was hit with a paternity suit from a fan who claimed Justin fathered her child, he
recognized the risk to his squeaky-clean brand image. Guided by PR rep Matthew Hiltzik, Bieber delivered an unequivocal denia
l on the "Today" show.
Team Bieber then went one better by filing a countersuit and taking a paternity test to prove he was no baby daddy.
His comment, "I know that I'm going to be a target, but I'm never going to be a victim," hit the right notes. Case closed.
Talk about facing the music. The J & J tampon brand was threatened with a "girlcott" by angry users after it discontinued its popular Ultra item.
The customer backlash threatened to take over its reputation, until o.b. defused the situation with a unique response
Its apology PR campaign included a hilarious video that used personalization technology to woo back customers. "Triple Sorry
" was a sublime send-up of an uber-schmaltzy music video, complete with rainbows and rose petals
and a vow to bring back the product. It was a pitch perfect response to a potential crisis.
He's known for flying by the seat of his pants, but the Speaker showed real PR savvy when he needed it most, just before the high-stakes South Carolina
primary. His ex-wife's ABC interview where she claimed he asked her for an "open marriage" could have dealt his campaign a death blow. But when CNN's
John King raised it at the start of the live debate, Gingrich was ready. He denied the story but not before exploding in indignation and casting the
media as the true guilty party.
It may not be enough to save his candidacy in the long run, but it was an ideal strategy that enabled Gingrich to rally his base against what they
might perceive as a common enemy.
Dorothy Crenshaw is CEO and creative director of Crenshaw Communications. She has been named one of the public relations industry's 100 Most
Powerful Women by PR Week. A version of this story appeared on MENGBlend and the Crenshaw Communications blog.