How to handle media interviewers that ask for guarantees

When responding to a crisis, the public wants to know for certain that mistakes won’t be repeated. Here’s how to navigate this sticky situation.

How to handle interviewers who ask for guarantees

Communicators always want to make promises they know they can keep, even when their organization is in full-blown crisis.

For example, if there has been a terrible train crash and people have died, at some point the CEO of the train operator or perhaps a politician will be asked a variation of “can you guarantee this won’t happen again.” Or perhaps the crisis is a data breach and the spokesperson could well be asked, “Can you ensure this never happens again?”

The temptation, of course, in both these examples is to issue a guarantee. It sounds bold and reassuring.

However, this is a question that can take spokespeople down a dangerous path, because offering this sort of guarantee is riddled with risk. How on earth can you guarantee such a thing will never occur again?

Issuing a guarantee simply makes organizations and their spokespeople hostages to fortune, promising something that they can’t live up to. It’s a response that can tee up future embarrassment.

This question can easily feel like a no-win situation, because saying that you can’t confirm something bad won’t happen again can also create uninspiring headlines such as:

  • “RBS boss can’t guarantee scandals won’t happen on his watch”
  • “Network Rail boss apologises for over running engineering work but says he can’t guarantee it won’t happen again”
  • “Heathrow cannot guarantee snow disruption won’t happen again, says airport chief”

If guaranteeing something won’t happen again is fraught with danger, and saying that you cannot make any promises leads to negative headlines, how can spokespeople manage this daunting question? The answer is to slightly and subtly shift the conversation by focusing on what you can guarantee during the crisis incident.

A CEO, for example, could guarantee that she is personally taking control of the situation. She could guarantee that an incident will be fully investigated and that lessons will be learnt from what has happened. She could guarantee that there will be changes to policies or procedures as a result of the incident. Perhaps she could promise there will be a new training program for staff.

These responses all sound positive, proactive and confident, but, importantly, they do not commit the organization to anything it cannot live up to—and they won’t lead to damaging headlines.

Of course, the journalist could push and ask whether your response is a guarantee that the same thing won’t happen again. Avoid getting drawn in to answering this exact question, and instead repeat what you can guarantee.

There might not be any guarantees in life, but this approach is your best bet to handle a thorny interview.

Adam Fisher is the content editor for Media First, a media and communications training firm. A version of this article originally appeared on the Media First blog.

COMMENT Daily Headlines

Sign up to receive the latest articles from directly in your inbox.