Why journalists should respond to PR pros’ emails

Reporters’ inboxes are constantly stuffed with story pitches and press releases, but one editor says replying can relieve a common complaint.

Journalists have a serious communication problem.

We like to vent about bad PR practices, and sometimes it’s well-deserved. Yet every time I’ve turned the tables and asked PR pros what bugs them most about us, the answer is always the same: Journalists don’t answer their emails.

On one hand, it’s understandable. We get dozens, even hundreds, of new pitches every single day. Trying to keep up with the constant influx is a daunting task, even for the most organized journalists. I’ve often heard fellow reporters say that if they answered every email they received, they’d never get anything else done.

On the other hand, PR pros have a job to do, too. Every unanswered pitch leads to a frustrated client or boss demanding to know why they didn’t get the lead. That’s why those “annoying” second and third follow-up emails (and phone calls) keep coming in if reporters ignore a pitch: The PR rep needs to be able to say they tried.

Even those extra efforts are often fruitless. As Large Media co-founder Micah Warren put it in his recent Muck Rack post, “If I had a nickel for every unreturned pitch to a journalist, I’d be typing this article on my iPad on my yacht.”

Having been on both sides, I can sympathize with each party’s struggle. As a journalist, I’ve found that the best way to stem the tide of follow-ups is to just answer the emails in the first place. In a lot of cases, PR pros will gladly accept a curt “no” over radio silence. Their client may wish they knew the reason, but at least they won’t be holding out hope for coverage that will never come.

How journalists can make it easier on themselves

You can’t and shouldn’t take the time to compose a personalized response to every pitch you get. By setting ground rules and writing up a few stock responses, you’ll be able to knock out replies to the majority of PR pros who pitch you—without letting your inbox take over your workday.

To accomplish this, I follow three basic rules with external emails:

1. Threads for active stories are addressed ASAP.

2. All new pitches and pitch follow-ups get filed away upon receipt to a separate folder, where they will sit until I have a block of free time to answer them.

3. Obvious mass pitches (i.e., BCCed recipient list, no greeting, etc.) don’t get a response unless I can use it.

When I do have time to sift through my new pitch folder, I do so knowing that I probably can’t use most of the pitches I’ve gotten. A while back, I took a few minutes to write up a series of scenario-appropriate responses that could easily be copied, pasted and sent in a matter of seconds. These ready-to-send answers work for almost every pitch I have to reject:

  • Irrelevant pitches: I don’t cover this, but thank you anyway.
  • Relevant, but not interested: I’m not interested in this story idea, but I appreciate your thinking of us.
  • Relevant, but too busy to cover: I don’t have room on my calendar to cover this right now, but I’ll keep your client in mind for future stories.

This approach solves two problems at once: It gives PR reps something to go back to their client with, and it keeps them from inundating your inbox with more emails about the rejected pitch. Plus, it’s a little more courteous than just saying, “No,” despite its taking just a few seconds longer.

How PR pros can make it easier on journalists

Send us your pitches through platforms like Muck Rack, HARO (Help a Reporter Out) and PressRush. These tools give reporters the option to click a button and automatically respond yes or no, which makes it faster and easier for us to give you an answer.

If you’re going the traditional route of direct email, please be patient with us as we work through our daily barrage of pitches. Follow up if you don’t hear from us: It’s very likely that we either haven’t read your email yet or it slipped through the cracks.

However, try to wait at least 24 hours before sending a follow-up, and don’t do it more than twice. I’ll always firmly believe that we reporters should respond to pitches, but if your third email goes unanswered, you might want to take the hint.

So, journalists, what do you think? Will you start responding to your emails?

Nicole Fallon Taylor is the managing editor of Business News Daily, a resource for small business owners, entrepreneurs and job seekers. Follow her on Twitter @nfallontaylor. A version of this article originally appeared on Muck Rack, a service that enables you to find journalists to pitch, build media lists, get press alerts and create coverage reports with social media data.


(Image via by Bruno Girin / CC BY-SA 2.0)


Topics: PR


Ragan.com Daily Headlines

Sign up to receive the latest articles from Ragan.com directly in your inbox.